Can You Refreeze Ice Cream?

During the warm summer months, it might be wonderful to have a container of ice cream on hand so that you can treat yourself to a delicious, frozen treat whenever the mood strikes. It’s not always easy to keep ice cream frozen because of things like power outages, broken freezers, and the like. I guess you’re wondering if there’s any way to save the melted ice cream. And can ice cream be safely thawed and refrozen for later use?

It’s not a good idea to refreeze ice cream since the consistency might change to something unpleasant. Refreezing ice cream that has melted only a little bit is fine, but melting it all the way is not. Homemade ice cream is best consumed within a week of preparation, whereas store-bought ice cream can be refrozen for up to a year if unopened.

Whether or not the ice cream successfully refreezes is contingent on several circumstances. Therefore, learning the fundamental methods and procedures for freezing ice cream that has partially or fully melted is crucial. Refreezing handmade and store-bought ice cream has various effects on each, as well as varied procedures, warnings, and time restrictions.

About Refreezing Ice Cream

Homemade ice cream shouldn’t be thawed and refrozen. If you make your own ice cream, it’s better to eat it as soon as possible once it’s finished freezing.

There is a considerable danger of bacteria growth in handmade ice cream since it lacks preservatives. Homemade ice cream may easily become tainted and dangerous to eat after being created.

It’s acceptable to refreeze melted store-bought ice cream, but doing so will alter the flavor and texture, making it less desirable. The likelihood of bacteria growth in the ice cream increases dramatically when it has totally melted.

It is perfectly fine to refreeze ice cream that has melted or softened. Some melting or thawing of ice cream is fine; it won’t ruin the flavor or texture too much if you put it back in the freezer.

Ice cream that has been softened can be stored in the freezer for a long time.

Ice cream that has melted or been improperly refrozen poses a significant health risk and may lead to food poisoning if consumed. There’s a chance the food’s flavor, texture, and overall quality will suffer as a result.

Please be aware that ice cream that has been out of the freezer for more than two hours should not be refrozen or consumed.

Why You Shouldn’t Refreeze Melted Ice Cream

It’s not worth the effort to try to refreeze ice cream that has already melted. The ice cream’s flavor and texture would suffer too much, and the hazards would be too great.

There are three basic reasons why melted ice cream should never be refrozen:

It’s not safe

Eggs are a common addition to the dairy product. Bacteria that are detrimental to human health can proliferate rapidly if a substance is allowed to sit at room temperature or in a warm environment for a prolonged period of time.

Since ice cream must first be frozen, this can be a slow process; nonetheless, if the ice cream is exposed to direct sunlight for an extended period of time or is kept at room temperature for too long, it will melt.

Listeria is a major cause of alarm since it can cause life-threatening food poisoning.

There are alterations to the texture

Uniform, little ice crystals form during the first freezing of ice cream. Once the ice cream melts, more ice crystals develop, creating a gritty texture that is unpleasant to consume.

The ice cream will have the consistency of finely crushed ice rather than a smooth, velvety consistency.

Reduced air bubles

In the churning process, air is included in the ice cream, creating fluffy, creamy ice cream.

If you let your ice cream melt, the air you whipped into it will escape, leaving you with a solid block of ice cream that needs to be re-churned to restore its airy texture after thawing.

Can partially thawed ice cream be refrozen for later use?

Leaving ice cream out, even in a cold place, can cause it to melt, but if it hasn’t entirely melted, you can safely refreeze it. Be sure the ice cream is still slightly frozen or at least has ice crystals visible.

That way, the texture won’t be drastically altered when frozen again, and no more air will be wasted in the process. The ice cream’s texture and lightness may alter slightly, but not as much as if it had totally melted and then been refrozen.

Bacteria, including the particularly worrisome listeria, only develop fast at room temperature or warmer; therefore, if the ice cream has been kept cold, the risk of bacterial growth is lower.

You’ll have to use your best judgment to determine if the ice cream has defrosted too much to be refrozen, but it’s better to err on the side of caution than risk eating melted ice cream.

When in doubt, replace the tub altogether. It’s not worth risking illness for ice cream that doesn’t taste just right.

Is it possible to refreeze ice cream left out at room temperature overnight?

No matter how chilly the weather is, ice cream should never be left out of the freezer or refrigerator for more than a few hours.

Ice cream should not be left out at temperatures between 40 and 140 degrees Fahrenheit for more than 2 hours, since bacteria can grow fast in this range.

Keep ice cream out for no more than two hours before serving, and return it to the freezer if it hasn’t completely defrosted. Even handmade ice cream is not immune to this rule.

There’s a chance you can refreeze ice cream that’s been in the fridge overnight, but you’ll need to assess how much it’s softened before deciding.

If you leave ice cream out at room temperature, it won’t take all night to melt. At room temperature, the milk, sugar, and other liquids in ice cream create an ideal environment for the growth of bacteria.

Using a dirty spoon to eat ice cream straight from the container will only worsen this situation. The ice cream will soon be infested with microorganisms that will only grow.

Can ice cream be frozen and thawed several times?

It is possible to properly refreeze partially melted ice cream several times by following the refreezing instructions to the letter each time. Even if the ice cream has melted a little, you can put it back in the freezer and use it again and again without worrying about spoiling.

But it’s not good for you to refreeze ice cream that’s fully melted. The final product has a gritty texture and may induce serious disease.

How To Refreeze Ice Cream Correctly

Recipe for Refreezing Ice Cream:

Safe refreezing of ice cream can be achieved by adhering to the procedures outlined below:

  1. As a first step, examine the fridge’s cold storage to see if it is at the right temperature. If you want to securely refreeze ice cream, you must keep it in temperatures of 0 degrees Fahrenheit or lower.
  2. Then, once the freezer is at the correct temperature, place the flat container of ice cream in the freezer. Don’t overfill the container; leave at least half an inch of headroom for expansion while refreezing.
  3. If you don’t want ice crystals to develop on the top of your ice cream, place a plastic sheet on the surface. Taking these precautions can also protect you from freezer burns.
  4. Second, ensure that the ice cream is well-sealed before storing it so that it doesn’t melt or lose its consistency.
  5. Labeling the ice cream container can help you keep track of when it was refrozen.
  6. The final step for successfully refreezing ice cream is storing the container in the coldest region of the freezer. Keep the ice cream container away from the freezer door when refreezing. Put the container somewhere that stays frozen.

How To Tell If Refrozen Ice Cream Has Gone Bad?

The expiration date on refrozen food isn’t always easy to determine. However, there are several telltale symptoms that the ice cream has gone bad that you can keep an eye out for.

  • When ice cream is kept in the freezer for too long, ice crystals develop on the surface. You shouldn’t eat ice cream that has formed ice crystals.
  • Similar to the flavor, the ice cream’s deteriorated texture indicates that it has gone bad. Creams having a gritty or thick consistency shouldn’t be eaten as often. It may not harm your health, but it won’t taste or feel good.
  • The ice cream’s sour fragrance will tell you if it’s gone bad. Toss it out if you detect a strange or unpleasant odor.

It’s best to avoid ice cream if you have any of these symptoms.


How long can ice cream remain fresh in the freezer if it has not been opened?

Ice cream has a shelf life of up to 12 months if stored unopened in its original packaging. A steady temperature of 0 degrees Fahrenheit is required.

The ice cream’s shelf life is affected by how well it is stored; hence, better storage results in a longer ice cream shelf life.

After the date on the ice cream container, is it safe to eat it?

If there are no visible symptoms of spoilage, then eating ice cream over its expiration date is typically safe. There should be some sort of “best by,” “best before,” or “best used by” date on the ice cream tub, although this date is not always a safety date.

After these dates, the ice cream’s quality should start to degrade. The ice cream may still be OK after that time has passed.

If you take the ice cream out of the freezer, how long until it melts?

The shelf life of ice cream is around two hours when removed from the freezer. Any food that has been out for more than that amount of time should be discarded.


Softened ice cream can be saved from being wasted by being refrozen carefully. If you don’t want to wait for the entire tub of ice cream to thaw before you can enjoy it, consider refreezing it in individual servings.

An unopened tub of ice cream may stay frozen for up to a year.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *